Warning issued as inaccurate valuations land WA valuer in hot water

In addition, he was implicated for his failure to “provide sufficient explanation in respect of assumptions made or methodologies used to form the estimate of value”.

He was tried for valuations conducted between February 2018 and May 2019, with each conviction related to four separate land titles in Cannington, Bentley, Breton Bay, and Spalding, with all properties owned by the same group of companies.

Despite his 40-year experience, Mr MacEwan was found to have carried out his work without complying with the industry’s “accepted principles and practices”, which may have resulted in the production of inaccurate estimates.

Gary Newcombe, commissioner for consumer protection, said accurate valuations are crucial for the industry’s reputation. 

“The credibility of the industry is at stake, so established practices and acceptable standards need to be maintained at all times by licensed valuers to uphold the community’s confidence in the property industry,” he said.

He described how undervalued or overvalued estimations can have wide-reaching and serious financial implications for buyers and sellers, as well as create tax complications. 

Mr Newcombe acknowledges that “poor valuations are difficult to detect as unsuspecting clients usually accept them at face value”; however, he advises that “anyone who has doubts about the accuracy of a valuation should contact Consumer Protection”.

“Considering the length of time that Mr MacEwan has spent in the industry, there is no excuse for his sub-standard work and for not carrying out his duties in accordance with the Australian valuation industry’s accepted principles and practices,” he concluded.